THE WORLD FOOD SITUATION
9
established that internal-
ize the positive and
negative externalities
of biofuels and ensure
that the energy out-
put from biofuel pro-
duction is greater
than the amount of
energy used in the
process. In general,
subsidies for biofuels
that use agricultural
production resources
are extremely anti-
poor because they
implicitly act as a tax
on basic food, which
represents a large
share of poor people’s
consumption expendi-
tures and becomes
even more costly as
prices increase, as shown above (von Braun 2007).
Great technological strides are expected in biofuel
production in the coming decades. New technologies
converting cellulosic biomass to liquid fuels would create
added value by both utilizing waste biomass and by using less
land resources.These second-generation technologies,
however, are still being developed and third-generation
technologies (such as hydrogene) are at an even earlier
phase. Even though future technology development will very
much determine the competitiveness of the sector, it will
not solve the food–fuel competition problem.The trade-offs
between food and fuel will actually be accelerated when
biofuels become more competitive relative to food and
when, consequently, more land, water, and capital are
diverted to biofuel production.To soften the trade-offs and
mitigate the growing price burden for the poor, it is
necessary to accelerate investment in food and agricultural
science and technologies, and the CGIAR has a vital role to
play in this. For many developing countries, it would be
appropriate to wait for the emergence of second-generation
technologies, and “leapfrog” onto them later.
Attempts to predict future overall food price changes
How will food prices change in coming years? This is one of
the central questions that policymakers, investors,
speculators, farmers, and millions of poor people ask.Though
the research community does its best to answer this
question, the many uncertainties created by supply, demand,
market functioning, and policies mean that no straightforward
answer can be given. However, a number of studies have
analyzed the forces driving the current increases in world
food prices and have predicted future price developments.
The Economic Intelligence Unit predicts an 11-percent
increase in the price of grains in the next two years and only a
5-percent rise in the price of oilseeds (EIU 2007).The OECD-
FAO outlook has higher price projections (it expects the
prices of coarse grains, wheat, and oilseeds to increase by 34,
20, and 13 percent, respectively, by 2016–17).The Food and
Agricultural Policy Research Institute (FAPRI) expects
increases in corn demand and prices to last until 2009–10, and
thereafter expects corn production growth to be on par with
consumption growth. FAPRI does not expect biofuels to have
a large impact on wheat markets, and predicts that wheat
prices will stay constant due to stable demand as population
growth offsets declining per capita consumption. Only the
price of palm oil—another biofuel feedstock—is projected to
dramatically increase by 29 percent. In cases where demand
for agricultural feedstock is large and elastic, some experts
expect petroleum prices to act as a price floor for agricultural
commodity prices. In the resulting price corridor, agricultural
commodity prices are determined by the product’s energy
equivalency and the energy price (Schmidhuber 2007).
In order to model recent price developments, changes in
supply and demand from 2000 to 2005 as well as biofuel
developments were introduced into the IFPRI IMPACT
model (see Scenario 1).The results indicate that biofuel pro-
duction is responsible for only part of the imbalances in the
world food equation. Other supply and demand shocks also
play important roles.The price changes that resulted from
actual supply and demand changes during 2000–2005 capture
a fair amount of the noted increase in real prices for grains in
those years (Figure 12).
6
For the period from 2006 to 2015,
the scenario suggests further increases in cereal prices of
about 10 to 20 percent in current U.S. dollars. Continued
depreciation of the U.S. dollar—which many expect—may
further increase prices in U.S.-dollar terms.
The results suggest that changes on the supply side
(including droughts and other shortfalls and the diversion of
food for fuel) are powerful forces affecting the price surge at
a time when demand is strong due to high income growth in
developing countries. Under a scenario of continued high
income growth (but no further supply shocks), the prelimi-
nary model results indicate that food prices would remain at
Table 5—Changes in world prices of feedstock crops and sugar by 2020 under
two scenarios compared with baseline levels (%)
SCENARIO 1 SCENARIO 2
Biofuel Drastic biofuel
Crop expansion
a
expansion
b
Cassava 11.2 26.7
Maize 26.3 71.8
Oilseeds 18.1 44.4
Sugar 11.5 26.6
Wheat 8.3 20.0
SOURCE: IFPRI IMPACT projections (in constant prices).
a
Assumptions are based on actual biofuel production plans and projections in relevant countries and regions.
b
Assumptions are based on doubling actual biofuel production plans and projections in relevant countries and regions.